Skip to content

Prop Consistency Rules: Positive Days vs Net Profit

Use the same daily ledger to see why the denominator changes the result.

Public-document research checked 8 October 2026. Examples are fictional; no challenge, pass, payout or paid account test is claimed.

Start With Daily Accounting

Write one closed daily result in the firm's defined timezone for every trading day. Preserve commissions and other adjustments under the contract's own convention. A positive day is not a winning trade; several trades can net into a losing day. A largest trade is not necessarily the best day. The worksheet assumes your entered daily summary has already been reconciled.

The generic variables are total positive-day profit P, absolute losing-day loss L and best positive day B. Net closed profit is P - L. Choose the denominator explicitly: P for a positive-days rule, or P - L for a net-profit rule. These are teaching categories, not a statement that every firm uses one of these exact formulas.

Work One Ledger Two Ways

Use fictional daily results of +$600, +$400, -$200 and +$200. Positive-day profit is $1,200, losing-day loss is $200 and net profit is $1,000. The best day is $600. Dividing by positive-day profit gives 50%; dividing by net profit gives 60%. The trades did not change; the accounting rule did.

At an assumed 50% threshold, the positive-days comparison meets the arithmetic boundary while the net-profit comparison does not. This is not a firm pass decision. Other objectives, open-position rules, minimum days and account review may still apply. Use the official rule's inclusive or exclusive boundary; this worksheet uses a generic at-most comparison only.

Understand the Additional-Profit Calculation

Holding B fixed, the required denominator is B / q, where q is the selected threshold expressed as a fraction. With B = $600 and q = 0.5, the required denominator is $1,200. Starting from $1,000 net profit, another $200 of net profit would meet that arithmetic threshold if the best day remains $600.

That last condition matters. A new +$800 day creates a new best day, so the old $200 calculation no longer describes the updated ledger. Further losing days also reduce net profit. The worksheet is a static sensitivity calculation, not a proposed trading plan. It does not recommend pursuing a target or increasing size to repair a ratio.

Handle Zero or Negative Denominators

If net profit is zero or negative, a best-day share of net profit is not a meaningful positive-profit ratio. The worksheet displays it as undefined rather than dividing by zero or producing a misleading negative percentage. A zero best day implies no positive-day profit in the reconciled input model. Inconsistent summaries are rejected.

Likewise, P cannot be less than B, because the best positive day is part of the positive-day total. The form cannot verify the underlying dates or the firm's fee convention. It only checks elementary consistency and evaluates the entered scenario. Retain the daily ledger alongside an export so another person can reconstruct the summary.

Use the Account's Rule, Not a Familiar Label

The rule passport records which denominator, threshold and purchase vintage apply. A current official announcement may change terminology for future accounts without changing older ones. Recheck documents at purchase and phase transition. Do not infer that consistency requirements are interchangeable across CFD, forex and futures programmes.

This publication has not bought an evaluation, completed a review or received a payout. The worksheet is browser-local arithmetic based on fictional defaults. Its result must not be called a pass forecast, compliance certification or account permission. The best use is finding a denominator error before it becomes part of a purchase decision.

Primary Sources

Prop Consistency Denominator Worksheet

Continue the Research

A changing numerator beside the original fixed-best formula

The full daily ledger derives best day from the supplied rows. Adding a fictional 1,500 day changes both the best day and net profit, leaving a sixty-percent net share. The original conditional calculation is retained for its unchanged-best premise. Neither scope forecasts recovery or recommends trading to repair a ratio.

Inspect the complete teaching population

The packet has seven invented account observations, six explicit policy cases and five base closed daily rows. It also retains missing-equity, unmodelled-flow, changing-best-day and undefined-denominator variants. Keep the active reference, monitored measure, operator and observation scope with each comparison. A true arithmetic condition is not a programme pass, and a later recovery does not erase an earlier supplied exception. No row is a participant outcome, broker event or payout record. Genuine account decisions require their own applicable documents and authoritative state.

Worked evaluation records